The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (2024)

Any lip liners will help define the shape of the lips to give your tried-and-true lipstick a little extra staying power. But coveted liners, like NARS' Precision Lip Liner and Chanel's Le Crayon Lèvres, can practically do it all. "Lip liner is a way to define your individual beauty," celebrity makeup artist Harold James tells Bazaar. "It's a versatile essential that can be worn alone, with gloss, or paired with lipstick to define the lips and prevent feathering."

Shop the Best Lip Liners

Matching your lip liner shade exactly to a go-to lipstick may seem like a no-brainer, but experts note that it's not always necessary. Having a liner harmonize with your chosen lipstick helps quickly add dimension to your overall makeup aesthetic.

"When you match your lip liner with your lipstick it gives you a seamless lip look, which traditionally lasts longer. I usually use this approach when doing a bold red or colored lip, such as purple," Ami Colé founder and CEO Diarrha N'Diaye-Mbaye says. "I usually find myself gravitating toward iterations of browns and peachy nudes and apply darker brown liner to set the base for a nude lip color. Using brown on brown reminds me of the '90s brown lip look, which is iconic but not my every day, though I am heavily inspired by it." Using slightly lighter or darker liner shades is an easy way to add even more depth to your overall lip shape, depending on your preference—and coordinating eye look.

To help streamline your options, we sifted through hundreds of customer reviews, considered Bazaar-approved favorites, and consulted top experts to narrow down some of the best lip liners worth shopping. Read on for some of the most versatile formulas—featuring beloved matte and creamy picks—to add to your daily rotation.

Best Long-Wearing

Chanel Le Crayon Lèvres

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (7)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (8)Great for travel
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (9)Features a non-drying formula
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (10)Does not include sharpener

This creamy, long-wearing liner perfectly coordinates with Chanel's range of lipstick shades (if you're into that). It also nicely features a built-in lip brush for expert blending and uses ingredients like jojoba oil and cotton seed derivatives to keep lips supple.

Number of shades available: 18

One satisfied customer writes: "Best lip pencil I've ever used!! I love the brush on the other end to blend the lipliner with the gloss or lipstick whichever you are using. Classic fabulous Chanel quality. Just magnificent!!" —Anonymous

Most Viral

Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (11)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (12)Waterproof
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (13)Does not include sharpener

Fans of Charlotte Tilbury's highly popular Pillow Talk lipstick may already own this liner version of the classic shade. For those who don't, may we suggest adding the versatile pick to your makeup bag? It's not only formulated to last for up to six hours but also comes in three additional variations to suit multiple skin tones.

Number of shades available: 23

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best for Beginners

Glossier Lip Line

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (14)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (15)Easy to use
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (16)Hydrating
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (17)Does not include sharpener

No matter which lip liner you decide to use, professionals note that the ones with creamy formulas are ideal for creating smooth, precise lines. "When aiming for a natural, no-makeup makeup look, I prefer using a creamy lip liner, like Glossier's Lip Line," James continues. These liners offer true-to-lip shades and are enriched with nourishing jojoba oil, ensuring that the lips
stay hydrated and never appear dry."

Number of shades available: Eight

One satisfied customer writes: "I adore the shades of these liners and was so excited to try them! The color payoff is true to Glossier fundamentals and very buildable. The neutral tone makes them more universal too. Applied smoothly and was a great base for my lipstick!" —Jill B.

Best Transfer-Resistant

Dior Rouge Dior Contour No-Transfer Lip Liner Pencil

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (18)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (19)Travel-friendly
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (20)Does not include sharpener

Here's another luxe liner from the experts at Dior that includes a pigmented color payoff and a handy built-in brush. The essential features hydrating ingredients like floral extracts and shea butter, and it also aims to last through up to eight hours of eating and drinking.

Number of shades available: 21

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best for Darker Skin Tones

Ami Colé Soft Shape Waterproof Lip Liner

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (21)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (22)Hydrating
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (23)Waterproof
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (24)Does not include sharpener

There's a reason this coveted liner has nearly a five-star rating from Sephora customers. Its moisturizing, waterproof formula has a creamy finish that makes it a breeze to draw even lines with no skips, thanks to a blend of marula oil, shea butter, and vitamin E. And when worn with Ami Colé's viral Lip Treatment Oil, just about any of the brand's matte finish liners make for the perfect '90s lip.

Number of shades available: Five

One satisfied customer writes: "This pairs beautifully with my warm-toned glosses, especially the new Dior bronze lip products. I personally like pencils you have to sharpen because they last longer on me. It was easy to apply and so far I have enjoyed the formula. The color is stunning." —CareyC

Best Waterproof

Victoria Beckham Beauty Lip Definer

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (25)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (26)Hydrating
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (27)Easy to use
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (28)Limited color options

Who wouldn't want to look more like Victoria Beckham? You'll get that much closer after using this velvety liner from her namesake brand Victoria Beckham Beauty. Its waterproof formula makes getting a fuller pout simple and even contains palmitoyl tripeptide to help reduce fine lines around the mouth.

Number of shades available: Seven

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Best Matte

Make Up Forever Artist Color Pencil Longwear Lip Liner

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (30)Long-wearing
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (31)Features a creamy formula
Cons
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (32)Doesn't include sharpener

Over 1,200 Sephora shoppers swear by Make Up Forever's backstage-worthy lip liner pencil, which has an ultra-creamy formula and matte finish. Since the pencil is also full-coverage, it's highly pigmented when worn alone, but also looks great when topped with gloss or lipstick.

Number of shades available: 11

One satisfied customer writes: "I use this every time I leave the house. Amazing. Glides so smoothly and lasts a long time. The colors are perfection. Sharpens nicely." dria30

Best for Lip Sculpting

Lisa Eldridge Sculpt And Shade Lip Pencil

The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (33)

Pros
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (34)Easy to use
  • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (35)Hydrating
Cons

    Created by celebrity makeup artist Lisa Eldridge, this liner is made with expert precision in mind. Its soft matte formula is extremely blendable and glides over lips with minimal pressure.

    Number of shades available: 10

    One satisfied customer writes: "Very easy to use without making a mistake (I don't have the patience). Soft in a good way. I have aging around my lips and it doesn't dry out in the lines. Nude shades are very flattering. Actually does what I expected from a lip pencil. Will buy more shades." —Jen

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    Best for Lipstick

    NARS Cosmetics Precision Lip Liner

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (37)Long-lasting formula
    Cons
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (38)Doesn't include a sharpener

    We couldn't round up the best lip liners without including this classic staple from NARS. A little of its matte finish formula goes a long way and combines vitamin E, silk powder, and mango seed oil for supreme hydration.

    Number of shades available: 18

    One satisfied customer writes: "This lip liner stays put even with eating and drinking. I highly recommend." —Kimber63

    Best Overall

    MAC Cosmetics Lip Pencil

    The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (39)

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (40)Features a wide range of shade options
    Cons
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (41)May not be as hydrating as other lip liners

    From their baby pink Edge to Edge shade to the cult-favorite Whirl and Cork tones, MAC Cosmetics lip liners make completing your makeup look easy. Use it before applying your favorite lipstick shade for extra staying power, or after to refine your look.

    Number of shades available: 28

    One satisfied customer writes: "I love MAC lip liner. They glide like butter and also can be worn on their own. I recently purchased a bunch of lip products and I am super impressed with all. This lip liner is long-lasting and stays in place throughout the day." —Lata

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    Best with Brush

    Makeup by Mario Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (43)Travel-friendly
    Cons
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (44)May not be as hydrating as other lip liners

    Makeup by Mario's dual-ended lip pencil is a viral TikTok hit due to its emollient-rich, full-coverage formula that's designed with an artist's eye. It also uses a proprietary lip-lock formula that helps prevent bleeding and feathering as you wear it and a contour-shape technology that's prime for the trending overlined look.

    Number of shades available: 23

    One satisfied customer writes: "Mario has the best lip liners in my opinion. They work and look so good on my skin tone. I love that they’re not too creamy but not dry. They have the perfect consistency. I hate a liner that’s way too creamy." —Alansmomma

    Best Drugstore

    Maybelline Lifter Liner Lip Liner with Hyaluronic Acid

    The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (45)

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (46)Hydrating
    Cons
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (47)Doesn't include a sharpener

    This popular lip liner is made with hyaluronic acid, which makes it perfect for those looking for a little bit of a plumping effect. It also features jojoba oil, which helps the pencil smoothly glide against your lips for maximum color payoff.

    Number of shades available: 10

    One satisfied customer writes: "I really enjoy the color payoff and longevity of this lip liner! Very easy to apply and a beautiful neutral color! I paired it with a Lifter Gloss on top and worked perfectly! Highly recommend!"samanthaw287

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    Best for Blending

    Pat McGrath Labs Permagel Ultra Lip Pencil

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (49)Includes a sharpener
    Cons
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (50)Limited color range

    You won't have to worry about this gel-based liner setting before you have a chance to blend it out. Its soft, featherweight formula comes in pearl and matte finishes and also happens to be transfer-proof for all-day wear.

    Number of shades available: Eight

    One satisfied customer writes: "I have this product in several shades. Absolutely worth every penny! This glides on seamlessly for an effortless application without drying lips. Great alone, with lip balm or lipstick." —PrissyGalore

    Best Value

    e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Glide Lip Liner

    The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (51)

    Pros
    • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (52)Under $5
    Cons

      It's hard to beat the quality of e.l.f's Cream Glide lip liner, especially since it's priced at just $2. The creamy formula nicely fills in lips without tugging and leaves behind a semi-matte finish that works with a number of lipstick finishes.

      Number of shades available: Eight

      One satisfied customer writes: "Love it! I’ve bought cheap lip liners in packs from other stores and they were not creamy or easy to apply at all! I was really surprised to see how creamy this lip liner is and how they glide on so easily and are comfortable to apply. I got the shade truth or bare and I loveeee it! And they’re cheap too?? Amazing product, seriously!!" —brid10288

      Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

      Best for Overlining

      Jones Road Beauty The Lip Pencil

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (53)

      Pros
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (54)Easy to use
      Cons
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (55)Only available in natural finish tones

      Bazaar editors are fans of just about everything makeup legend Bobbi Brown makes, including this your-lips-but-better liner. From a cool nude to a rich chocolate brown, there's an effortless shade match for almost every skin tone.

      Number of shades available: Eight

      One satisfied customer writes: "I love the color and how it feels on my lips." —Judy B.

      Best for a Natural Finish

      RMS Beauty Go Nude Lip Pencil

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (56)

      Pros
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (57)Hydrating
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (58)Features natural ingredients
      Cons
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (59)Does not include a sharpener

      Shoppers in the know are raving about RMS Beauty's long-wearing lip liners. Their formula seamlessly defines the lip's natural shape without the threat of feathering or bleeding since they're packed with jojoba, sunflower, and meadowfoam seed oils, along with hydrating shea butter. And did we mention it has nearly a five-star rating among Credo Beauty customers?

      Number of shades available: Seven

      One satisfied customer writes: "Haven’t worn a lip liner in a while but I love this one. Makes my lips look fuller." —Angelica...

      Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

      Best Customizable

      Mansai 7 Eye and Lip Definer

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (60)

      Pros
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (61)Versatile
      Cons
      • The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (62)Doesn't feature wide color range

      Since you can use this pencil on both your eyes and lips, you'll get plenty of bang for your buck with its creamy color payoff. And as the definer also happens to be highly blendable, it's easier than ever to smudge out your eyeliner for a grunge-inspired makeup look.

      Number of shades available: Six

      One satisfied customer writes: "This is the prettiest and most luxurious color lip pencil I've used in a long time. I also dab it on my cheeks to match." —Anonymous

      Meet the experts

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (63)

      • Harold James is a celebrity makeup artist based in Paris.
      • Diarrha N'Diaye-Mbaye is the founder and CEO of Ami Colé.

      Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

      How should lip liner be applied?

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (64)

      Experts recommend following the below steps for seamless lip liner application:

      1. Sharpen your pencil for precision.
      2. Outline lips from the cupid's bow, gradually moving towards the corners.
      3. Fill in lips with the liner, laying a foundation for lipstick adherence.
      4. Blend slightly towards the center for a subtle gradient effect, if you want. This will create the appearance of fuller lips in a subtle way.
      5. Complete the look by layering it with your favorite lipstick or gloss.

      "My personal go-to for applying lip liner is outlining lips to your desired shape, then working inward toward the center," N'Diaye-Mbaye says. "I spend extra time on my cupid's bow and the outer corners of my lips—it pulls the combination together. For a more pronounced statement, I’ll add depth and dimension by using a lighter shade on the inside of a darker liner. It makes me feel pulled together, similar to when you finally iron your shirt and step out!"

      Should lip liner exactly match your preferred lipstick shade?

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (65)

      "While lip liners do not need to match your lipstick perfectly, they should harmonize for a dimensional and chic look," James says. "I recommend experimenting with lighter or darker shades for added depth." N'Diaye-Mbaye agrees, adding that lip liner serves as a frame to a person's overall look. "Lipstick can fade, but if you have the right waterproof lip liner, you’ve got the base of your lip look locked in," she explains. "It’s almost like how the brows can frame a whole face, similar to that, a well-defined lip with lip liner does the same, elevating your entire makeup expression."

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (66)

      Tiffany Dodson

      Associate Beauty Commerce Editor

      Tiffany Dodson Davis is the associate beauty commerce editor at Harper’s Bazaar. Don't ask her to choose a favorite fragrance—it's like picking a favorite child. As one of the brand's resident shopping experts, she specializes in trend forecasting, testing the latest beauty and wellness launches, and curating bookmark-worthy commerce guides. Tiffany's work has previously been featured in SELF Magazine, Bustle, and Teen Vogue. She's also been tapped as a commerce and beauty expert for The Business of Fashion, NPR’s Life Kit podcast, and more.

      The 17 Best Lip Liners Your Makeup Rotation Deserves (2024)

      References

      Top Articles
      Latest Posts
      Recommended Articles
      Article information

      Author: Manual Maggio

      Last Updated:

      Views: 5580

      Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

      Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

      Author information

      Name: Manual Maggio

      Birthday: 1998-01-20

      Address: 359 Kelvin Stream, Lake Eldonview, MT 33517-1242

      Phone: +577037762465

      Job: Product Hospitality Supervisor

      Hobby: Gardening, Web surfing, Video gaming, Amateur radio, Flag Football, Reading, Table tennis

      Introduction: My name is Manual Maggio, I am a thankful, tender, adventurous, delightful, fantastic, proud, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.